Note: all dates and times are from yahoo groups using a +0 time zone Proposals: +------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | |Proposal Name|Proposal Body |Proposal |Votes |Notes | | | | |Status |Cast | | |--+-------------+---------------+--------------+--------+---------------| |1 |"Proposal 1" |The follow rule|Submitted on |FOR: | | | | |be created: |Thu, 10 Apr |AGAINST:| | | | |10.5 An office |2003 at |ABSTAIN:| | | | |exists known as|10:44am by |NO VOTE | | | | |the 'Proposal |Cassie Harley |CAST: | | | | |Officer' | |bd | | | | | |Not Pending |Cassie | | | | |The follow rule|due to TSL |Craig | | | | |be created: |violations |Dr | | | | |10.6 The job of| |Ducker | | | | |the 'Proposal |Expired on |unlin_e | | | | |Officer' shall |Thu, 17 Apr | | | | | |be to ensure |2003 at | | | | | |proposals are |10:44am | | | | | |correctly | | | | | | |processed. |Destroyed by | | | | | | |"Spring | | | | | |The follow rule|Cleaning" | | | | | |be created: | | | | | | |10.7 If the | | | | | | |position of | | | | | | |'Proposal | | | | | | |Officer' is | | | | | | |vacated, then | | | | | | |it is the duty | | | | | | |of the | | | | | | |'Speaker' to | | | | | | |call an | | | | | | |election. | | | | | | | | | | | | | |The follow rule| | | | | | |be created: | | | | | | |5.9 The owner | | | | | | |of the proposal| | | | | | |may process the| | | | | | |proposal | | | | | | |eyself. | | | | | | | | | | | | | |The follow rule| | | | | | |be created: | | | | | | |5.10 If the | | | | | | |owner has | | | | | | |incorrectly | | | | | | |processed a | | | | | | |proposal it | | | | | | |will be deemed | | | | | | |to have | | | | | | |expired. | | | | | | | | | | | | | |The follow rule| | | | | | |be created: | | | | | | |5.11 A proposal| | | | | | |is processed | | | | | | |when it has | | | | | | |been submitted | | | | | | |to the mailing | | | | | | |list with a | | | | | | |subject heading| | | | | | |as follows | | | | | | |'Proposal X', | | | | | | |where X is the | | | | | | |next number | | | | | | |following in | | | | | | |chronological | | | | | | |order from the | | | | | | |number of the | | | | | | |last proposal. | | | | | | | | | | | | | |The following | | | | | | |rule be | | | | | | |deleted: | | | | | | |5.2 A pending | | | | | | |proposal is a | | | | | | |proposal which | | | | | | |obeys the Three| | | | | | |Sacred Laws, | | | | | | |has been | | | | | | |submitted to | | | | | | |the official | | | | | | |mailing list, | | | | | | |and has not | | | | | | |expired. | | | | | | | | | | | | | |The follow rule| | | | | | |be created: | | | | | | |5.2 A pending | | | | | | |proposal is a | | | | | | |proposal which | | | | | | |obeys the Three| | | | | | |Sacred Laws, | | | | | | |has been | | | | | | |processed, and | | | | | | |has not | | | | | | |expired. | | | | |--+-------------+---------------+--------------+--------+---------------| |2 | |Destroy 7.3 |Submitted on |FOR: |+1 Therm | | | |Create: |Thu, 10 Apr |bd | | | | |7.3 When a |2003 at |Craig | | | | |player |09:35pm by bd |Dr | | | | |deregisters, | |Ducker | | | | |one of eir |Pending |Josh | | | | |points is | |unlin_e | | | | |destroyed, and |Expired on |AGAINST:| | | | |all eir points |Thu, 17 Apr |ABSTAIN:| | | | |and things |2003 at |NO VOTE | | | | |are distributed|09:35pm |CAST: | | | | |randomly | |Cassie | | | | |between all |Passed | | | | | |other players. | | | | | | | |Destroyed by | | | | | | |"Spring | | | | | | |Cleaning" | | | |--+-------------+---------------+--------------+--------+---------------| |3 |"Proposal 2" |Rule 1.1 is to |Submitted on |FOR: | | | | |be deleted, and|Thu, 10 Apr |unlin_e | | | | |replaced with a|2003 at |AGAINST:| | | | |new rule 1.1 |09:44pm by |Dr | | | | |reading "No |Craig Daniel |Ducker | | | | |proposal may be| |ABSTAIN:| | | | |submitted whose|Pending |bd | | | | |passage would | |NO VOTE | | | | |directly |Expired on |CAST: | | | | |increase the |Thu, 17 Apr |Cassie | | | | |number of |2003 at |Craig | | | | |Things in the |09:44pm | | | | | |game by more | | | | | | |than one, |Failed | | | | | |unless it is | | | | | | |explicitly |Destroyed by | | | | | |permitted by |"Spring | | | | | |rules in the |Cleaning" | | | | | |group headed | | | | | | |FIRST SACRED | | | | | | |LAW." | | | | | | | | | | | | | |Rule 1.2 is to | | | | | | |be deleted, and| | | | | | |replaced with a| | | | | | |new rule 1.2 | | | | | | |reading "A | | | | | | |Registration | | | | | | |Proposal may, | | | | | | |if passed, | | | | | | |increase the | | | | | | |number of | | | | | | |Things in the | | | | | | |game." | | | | | | | | | | | | | |A rule 1.0 is | | | | | | |to be added, | | | | | | |reading "The | | | | | | |rules in the | | | | | | |group headed | | | | | | |FIRST SACRED | | | | | | |LAW are in | | | | | | |temporary | | | | | | |hiatus and will| | | | | | |not be in force| | | | | | |until such time| | | | | | |as this rule is| | | | | | |repealed." | | | | | | | | | | | | | |The comment on | | | | | | |the FIRST | | | | | | |SACRED LAW will| | | | | | |be amended to | | | | | | |read, "Without | | | | | | |outside | | | | | | |influence, the | | | | | | |game cannot | | | | | | |expand at a | | | | | | |very high | | | | | | |rate." | | | | | | | | | | | | | |Rule 4.0 will | | | | | | |be deleted, but| | | | | | |players are | | | | | | |advised to | | | | | | |continue to use| | | | | | |short rules in | | | | | | |case of SSL | | | | | | |damage. | | | | |--+-------------+---------------+--------------+--------+---------------| |4 |"Proposal 3" |CREATE Rule |Submitted on |FOR: | | | | |5.9, "A therm |Thu, 10 Apr |AGAINST:| | | | |is destroyed |2003 at |bd | | | | |when a rule is |10:16pm by |Dr | | | | |created." |unlin_e |Ducker | | | | | | |ABSTAIN:| | | | | |Not Pending |NO VOTE | | | | | |due to TSL |CAST: | | | | | |violations |Cassie | | | | | | |Craig | | | | | |Expired on |unlin_e | | | | | |Thu, 17 Apr | | | | | | |2003 at | | | | | | |10:16pm | | | | | | | | | | | | | |Destroyed by | | | | | | |"Spring | | | | | | |Cleaning" | | | |--+-------------+---------------+--------------+--------+---------------| |5 |"Proposal 3, |CREATE Rule |Submitted on |FOR: | | | |Version 2" |5.9, "When a |Thu Apr 10, |AGAINST:| | | | |rule is |2003 at |bd | | | | |created, choose|10:28pm by |Dr | | | | |randomly |unlin_e |Ducker | | | | |between | |ABSTAIN:| | | | |destroying one |Not Pending |NO VOTE | | | | |therm and |due to TSL |CAST: | | | | |destroying two |violations |Cassie | | | | |therms." | |Craig | | | | | |Expired on Thu|unlin_e | | | | | |Apr 17, 2003 | | | | | | |at 10:28pm | | | | | | | | | | | | | |Destroyed by | | | | | | |"Spring | | | | | | |Cleaning" | | | |--+-------------+---------------+--------------+--------+---------------| |6 |"Proposal Dr.|Create a Rule: |Submitted on |FOR: |Can't Pass | | |Ducker::1" |5.9 When a rule|Thu Apr 10, |Dr | | | | |is created, |2003 at |Ducker | | | | |choose randomly|11:18pm by |AGAINST:| | | | |between |Doctor Ducker |bd | | | | |destroying one | |unlin_e | | | | |therm and |Pending |ABSTAIN:| | | | |destroying two | |Craig | | | | |therms. |Expired on Thu|NO VOTE | | | | | |Apr 17, 2003 |CAST: | | | | |Destroy this |at 11:18pm |Cassie | | | | |Proposal. | | | | | | | |Failed | | | | | | | | | | | | | |Destroyed by | | | | | | |"Spring | | | | | | |Cleaning" | | | |--+-------------+---------------+--------------+--------+---------------| |7 |"Let There be|(a) Delete rule|Submitted on |FOR: |There may be a | | |Josh" |9.1. |Fri Apr 11, |bd |CJF on who owns| | | | |2003 at |Craig |this proposal? | | | |(b) Create a |12:34am by |Dr | | | | |new rule 9.1, |Josh Millard |Ducker |Can't Fail | | | |which reads: |(Registration |AGAINST:|(unless it | | | |"Rules, |Proposal) |ABSTAIN:|isn't a valid | | | |players, | |NO VOTE |proposal) | | | |proposals, |Pending |CAST: | | | | |offices, | |Cassie |Josh is now a | | | |points, and |Expired on Fri|unlin_e |Player. | | | |kudoses are |Apr 18, 2003 | | | | | |Things." |at 12:34am | |+ 1 Therm | | | | | | |+ 1 Kudos in | | | |(c) Create one |Passed | |Josh Millard's | | | |kudos, which | | |possession | | | |belongs to Josh|Destroyed by | | | | | |Millard. |"Spring | | | | | | |Cleaning" | | | |--+-------------+---------------+--------------+--------+---------------| |8 |Craig's |Rule 0.3 is |Submitted on |FOR: |+ 1 Therm | | |untitled prop|destroyed and |Fri Apr 11, |bd | | | |(about |replaced with |2003 at 8:49pm|Craig | | | |randomizers) |"0.3 To |by Craig |unlin_e | | | | |ensure that | |AGAINST:| | | | |random |Pending |ABSTAIN:| | | | |selections | |NO VOTE | | | | |occur without |Expired on Fri|CAST: | | | | |fraud, |Apr 18, 2003 |Cassie | | | | |dice@pbm.com |at 8:49pm |Dr | | | | |shall be used | |Ducker | | | | |whenever |Passed |Josh | | | | |anything random| | | | | | |is called for."|Destroyed by | | | | | | |"Spring | | | | | | |Cleaning" | | | |--+-------------+---------------+--------------+--------+---------------| |9 |"The |Rule 10.3 is |Submitted on |FOR: | | | |Stenotype" |repealed and |Fri Apr 11, |Craig | | | | |replaced with a|2003 at 8:56pm|AGAINST:| | | | |new rule 10.3 |by Craig |ABSTAIN:| | | | |reading as | |NO VOTE | | | | |follows: |Not Pending |CAST: | | | | |10.3 The |due to TSL |bd | | | | |Speaker shall |violations |Cassie | | | | |be in charge of| |Dr | | | | |tabulating |Expired on Fri|Ducker | | | | |votes and |Apr 18, 2003 |Josh | | | | |making any |at 8:56pm |unlin_e | | | | |random | | | | | | |decisions that |Destroyed by | | | | | |the rules do |"Spring | | | | | |not ask another|Cleaning" | | | | | |player to make.| | | | | | | | | | | | | |Rule 10.5 is | | | | | | |created in the | | | | | | |group OFFICES, | | | | | | |reading: | | | | | | |There is an | | | | | | |office known as| | | | | | |the Stenotype, | | | | | | |whose posessor,| | | | | | |the | | | | | | |Stenographer, | | | | | | |is responsible | | | | | | |for tracking | | | | | | |all past | | | | | | |judgements and | | | | | | |for assigning | | | | | | |Judges and | | | | | | |Appelate | | | | | | |Justices. | | | | | | | | | | | | | |Rule 11.2 is | | | | | | |repealed and | | | | | | |replaced with | | | | | | |the a new rule | | | | | | |11.2 reading: | | | | | | |When a Call For| | | | | | |Judgement is | | | | | | |issued, the | | | | | | |Stenographer | | | | | | |shall randomly | | | | | | |choose a | | | | | | |player, who | | | | | | |shall be known | | | | | | |as the Judge. | | | | | | | | | | | | | |This proposal | | | | | | |is destroyed. | | | | | | | | | | | | | |A random player| | | | | | |is named | | | | | | |Stenographer. | | | | |--+-------------+---------------+--------------+--------+---------------| |10|"Spring |All non-pending|Submitted on |FOR: |+ 10 Therms | | |Cleaning" |proposals are |Fri Apr 11, |bd |- 10 Proposals | | | |destroyed. |2003 at |unlin_e | | | | | |09:59pm by |Craig |+ 1 point in | | | | |Craig Daniel |AGAINST:|Craig's | | | | | |Dr |possession | | | | |Pending |Ducker | | | | | | |ABSTAIN:| | | | | |Expired on Fri|NO VOTE | | | | | |Apr 18, 2003 |CAST: | | | | | |at 9:59pm |Cassie | | | | | | |Josh | | | | | |Passed | | | | | | | | | | | | | |Destroyed by | | | | | | |"Spring | | | | | | |Cleaning" | | | |--+-------------+---------------+--------------+--------+---------------| |11|"the |Rule 10.3 is |Submitted on |FOR: | | | |stenotype |repealed and |Sun Apr 13, |bd | | | |take 2" |replaced with a|2003 at |Craig | | | | |new rule 10.3 |10:11pm by |AGAINST:| | | | |reading as |Craig Daniel |ABSTAIN:| | | | |follows: | |NO VOTE | | | | |10.3 The |Not Pending |CAST: | | | | |Speaker shall |due to TSL |Cassie | | | | |be in charge of|violations |Dr | | | | |tabulating | |Ducker | | | | |votes and |Expired on Sun|Josh | | | | |making any |Apr 20, 2003 |unlin_e | | | | |random |at 10:11pm. | | | | | |decisions that | | | | | | |the rules do |Destroyed by | | | | | |not ask another|"the stenotype| | | | | |player to make.|take 3" | | | | | | | | | | | | |Rule 10.5 is | | | | | | |created in the | | | | | | |group OFFICES, | | | | | | |reading: | | | | | | |There is an | | | | | | |office known as| | | | | | |the Stenotype, | | | | | | |whose posessor,| | | | | | |the | | | | | | |Stenographer, | | | | | | |is responsible | | | | | | |for tracking | | | | | | |all past | | | | | | |judgements and | | | | | | |for assigning | | | | | | |Judges and | | | | | | |Appelate | | | | | | |Justices. | | | | | | | | | | | | | |Rule 11.2 is | | | | | | |repealed and | | | | | | |replaced with | | | | | | |the a new rule | | | | | | |11.2 reading: | | | | | | |When a Call For| | | | | | |Judgement is | | | | | | |issued, the | | | | | | |Stenographer | | | | | | |shall randomly | | | | | | |choose a | | | | | | |player, who | | | | | | |shall be known | | | | | | |as the Judge. | | | | | | | | | | | | | |This proposal | | | | | | |is destroyed. | | | | | | | | | | | | | |Proposal 2 is | | | | | | |destroyed. | | | | | | | | | | | | | |A random player| | | | | | |is named | | | | | | |Stenographer. | | | | |--+-------------+---------------+--------------+--------+---------------| |12|"Online polls|Rule 5.6 is |Submitted on |FOR: | | | |are fun" |repealed and |Sun Apr 13, |Craig | | | | |replaced with |2003 at |AGAINST:| | | | |the following: |10:21pm by |bd | | | | |"5.6 When a |Craig Daniel |ABSTAIN:| | | | |proposal | |NO VOTE | | | | |becomes |Pending |CAST: | | | | |pending, the | |Cassie | | | | |speaker shall |Expired on Sun|Dr | | | | |create a poll |Apr 20, 2003 |Ducker | | | | |where players |at 10:21pm. |Josh | | | | |are to cast | |unlin_e | | | | |their votes." |Failed | | | |--+-------------+---------------+--------------+--------+---------------| |13|untitled |For each |Submitted on |FOR: |+eprR (3) | | |registration |expired |Fri Apr 18, |AGAINST:|-eprPR (3) | | |proposal from|proposal in |2003 at 4:53am|Dr |+1R (6.8) | | |Ian Kelly. |existence, a |by Ian Kelly |Ducker |+1PL (Ian) | | | |rule is created| |ABSTAIN:|------------ | | | |with the text |Pending |Craig |+2 things | | | |"If this | |NO VOTE |+epr Therms (3)| | | |proposal is |Expired on Fri|CAST: | | | | |destroyed by a |Apr 25, 2003 |bd |Indirect | | | |proposal, a |at 4:53am. |Josh |Effects: | | | |point shall be | |unlin_e |Ian Kelly gets | | | |created in the |Failed |UNABLE |a Point under | | | |possession of | |TO VOTE:|rule 2.1 . | | | |the player who | |(Cassie)|All players | | | |possesses the | |(Ian) |recieve a point| | | |proposal.", and| | |under rule 1.3 | | | |with a number | | |. | | | |randomly chosen| | |Therms set to 0| | | |from the entire| | |under rule 1.3 | | | |space of the | | |. | | | |real numbers | | | | | | |not already | | | | | | |associated with| | | | | | |a rule. No, | | | | | | |perhaps that's | | | | | | |not in the | | | | | | |spirit of 0.2. | | | | | | |Let's just give| | | | | | |them | | | | | | |consecutive | | | | | | |integers | | | | | | |starting with | | | | | | |20. | | | | | | | | | | | | | |All expired | | | | | | |proposals are | | | | | | |destroyed. | | | | | | | | | | | | | |Rule 6.8 is | | | | | | |created in the | | | | | | |group "CHANGING| | | | | | |THE GAMESTATE",| | | | | | |reading | | | | | | |"Immediately | | | | | | |after a | | | | | | |proposal | | | | | | |expires, it is | | | | | | |destroyed; this| | | | | | |destruction is | | | | | | |not considered | | | | | | |to be a direct | | | | | | |effect of the | | | | | | |proposal." | | | | | | | | | | | | | |The number of | | | | | | |Therms is set | | | | | | |to forty-two. | | | | |--+-------------+---------------+--------------+--------+---------------| |14|"the |Rule 10.3 is |Submitted on |FOR: |-1R (10.3) | | |stenotype |repealed and |Sat Apr 19, |bd |+1R (10.3) | | |take 3" |replaced with a|2003 at |Craig |+1R (10.5) | | | |new rule 10.3 |12:22am by |Josh |-1R (11.2) | | | |reading as |Craig. |unlin_e |+1R (11.2) | | | |follows: | |AGAINST:|-1PR (this) | | | |10.3 The |Pending |Dr |-1PR (steno | | | |Speaker shall | |Ducker |take2) | | | |be in charge of|Expired on Thu|ABSTAIN:|+1O (stenotype)| | | |tabulating |Apr 24, 2003 |NO VOTE |------------- | | | |votes and |at 8:30pm. |YET: |-2R | | | |making any | |UNABLE |+3R | | | |random |Passed |TO VOTE:|-2PR | | | |decisions that | |(Cassie)|+1O | | | |the rules do |Destroyed by |(Ian) |----------- | | | |not ask another|"the stenotype| |+0 things | | | |player to make.|take 3" | |+4 Therms | | | | | | | | | | |Rule 10.5 is | | |Indirect | | | |created in the | | |Effects: | | | |group OFFICES, | | |Craig gets a | | | |reading: | | |Point under | | | |There is an | | |rule 2.1 | | | |office known as| | | | | | |the Stenotype, | | | | | | |whose posessor,| | | | | | |the | | | | | | |Stenographer, | | | | | | |is responsible | | | | | | |for tracking | | | | | | |all past | | | | | | |judgements and | | | | | | |for assigning | | | | | | |Judges and | | | | | | |Appelate | | | | | | |Justices. | | | | | | | | | | | | | |Rule 11.2 is | | | | | | |repealed and | | | | | | |replaced with | | | | | | |the a new rule | | | | | | |11.2 reading: | | | | | | |When a Call For| | | | | | |Judgement is | | | | | | |issued, the | | | | | | |Stenographer | | | | | | |shall randomly | | | | | | |choose a | | | | | | |player, who | | | | | | |shall be known | | | | | | |as the Judge. | | | | | | | | | | | | | |This proposal | | | | | | |is destroyed. | | | | | | | | | | | | | |the stenotype | | | | | | |take 2 is | | | | | | |destroyed. | | | | | | | | | | | | | |A random player| | | | | | |is named | | | | | | |Stenographer. | | | | |--+-------------+---------------+--------------+--------+---------------| |15|"transfers" |Add a rule 6.8 |Submitted on |FOR: |+1R | | | |in the group |Tue Apr 22, |bd |-1PR | | | |headed CHANGING|2003 at 2:56am|Craig |-------- | | | |THE GAMESTATE |by Craig. |unlin_e |+0 things | | | |reading "Any | |AGAINST:|+1 Therm | | | |player may give|Pending |ABSTAIN:| | | | |any Thing e | |Dr | ----------- | | | |posesses to any|Expired on Wed|Ducker | | | | |other player by|Apr 23, 2003 |Josh |Passage due to | | | |stating eir |at 7:27am. |NO VOTE |all eligible | | | |intent to do so| |CAST: |players voting.| | | |on the official|Passed. |UNABLE | | | | |mailing list." | |TO VOTE:| | | | | |Destroyed by |(Cassie)| | | | |If Ian Kelly's |this proposal.|(Ian) | | | | |registration | | | | | | |proposal has | | | | | | |passed, destroy| | | | | | |Ian Kelly. Just| | | | | | |kidding. | | | | | | |Instead, if it | | | | | | |has passed, | | | | | | |destroy rule | | | | | | |20. | | | | | | | | | | | | | |If Ian Kelly's | | | | | | |registration | | | | | | |proposal has | | | | | | |failed, destroy| | | | | | |this proposal. | | | | |--+-------------+---------------+--------------+--------+---------------| |16|"eco nomic |Destroy rule |Submitted on |FOR: |Votes AGAINST | | |stimulus |9.1 |Tue Apr 22, |bd |will | | |package" |Create a new |2003 at 3:18am|Craig |automatically | | | |rule 9.1 under |by Craig. |unlin_e |fail this | | | |the heading | |AGAINST:|proposal. | | | |THINGS with the|Pending |ABSTAIN:| | | | |text: | |Dr |R=Rules | | | |Rules, players,|Will expire on|Ducker |P=Points | | | |proposals, |Tue Apr 29, |NO VOTE |K=Kudos | | | |offices, coins,|2003 at |YET: |C=Coins | | | |points, kudos, |3:18am. |Josh |p=# of Points | | | |and The Bank | |UNABLE |k=# of Kudos | | | |are things. | |TO VOTE:|c=# of Coins | | | | | |(Cassie)| | | | |Destroy rule | |(Ian) | ----------- | | | |9.7 | | | | | | |Create a new | | |-1R (9.1) | | | |rule 9.7 under | | |+1R (9.1) | | | |the heading | | |-1R (9.7) | | | |THINGS with the| | |+1R (9.7) | | | |text: | | |+1R (15.0) | | | |Any Thing which| | |-1R (14.2) | | | |is not a | | |+pC | | | |player, Rule, | | |-pP | | | |or The Bank, | | |+kC | | | |must be | | |-kK | | | |possessed by a | | |+1R (15.1) | | | |player or The | | |-1R (15.1) | | | |Bank. | | |-1R (7.3) | | | | | | |+1R (7.3) | | | |Create a new | | |-1R (TSL1.3) | | | |rule 15.0 under| | |+1R (TSL1.3) | | | |the heading | | |-1R (TSL2.1) | | | |THINGS with the| | |+1R (TSL2.1) | | | |text: | | |---------------| | | |When the first | | |-7R | | | |proposal, after| | |+7R | | | |the creation of| | |+(p+k)C | | | |this rule, | | |-pP | | | |becomes | | |-kK | | | |expired, then | | |---------- | | | |at that time, | | |+0 things | | | |The Bank will | | |+7+(p+k) Therms| | | |be created, | | | | | | |1,000,000,000 | | |Indirect | | | |coins will be | | |Effects: | | | |created in the | | |Craig gets a | | | |possession of | | |coin under rule| | | |The Bank, and | | |2.1 | | | |this rule will | | | | | | |then be | | | | | | |destroyed. | | | | | | | | | | | | | |The comment for| | | | | | |the section | | | | | | |THINGS will | | | | | | |have the | | | | | | |following text | | | | | | |added to the | | | | | | |end of it: | | | | | | |Coins are | | | | | | |intended to be | | | | | | |a currency, and| | | | | | |The Bank is a | | | | | | |Thing which | | | | | | |posesses all | | | | | | |Coins not in | | | | | | |the posession | | | | | | |of a player. | | | | | | | | | | | | | |Destroy rule | | | | | | |14.2 | | | | | | | | | | | | | |For each point | | | | | | |in existence, | | | | | | |create a Coin | | | | | | |in the | | | | | | |posession of | | | | | | |the same | | | | | | |player. Destroy| | | | | | |all points. | | | | | | | | | | | | | |For each kudos | | | | | | |in existence, | | | | | | |create a Coin | | | | | | |in the | | | | | | |posession of | | | | | | |the same | | | | | | |player. Destroy| | | | | | |all kudoses. | | | | | | | | | | | | | |Create a new | | | | | | |rule 15.1 under| | | | | | |the heading | | | | | | |THERMODYNOMIC | | | | | | |with the text: | | | | | | |This rule | | | | | | |serves no | | | | | | |purpose. | | | | | | | | | | | | | |Destroy rule | | | | | | |15.1 | | | | | | |Why? Because we| | | | | | |can. Let's do | | | | | | |the | | | | | | |happy-dance. | | | | | | |Gosh, you can | | | | | | |really tell I'm| | | | | | |up too late | | | | | | |causing | | | | | | |economic | | | | | | |activity. | | | | | | |Imagine what | | | | | | |Alan Greenspan | | | | | | |goes through. | | | | | | | | | | | | | |Destroy rule | | | | | | |7.3 | | | | | | |Create a new | | | | | | |rule 7.3 under | | | | | | |the heading | | | | | | |DEREGISTRATION | | | | | | |with the text: | | | | | | |When a player | | | | | | |deregisters, | | | | | | |one of eir | | | | | | |Coins is | | | | | | |destroyed, and | | | | | | |all eir things | | | | | | |are distributed| | | | | | |randomly | | | | | | |between all | | | | | | |other players. | | | | | | | | | | | | | |Destroy rule | | | | | | |1.3 | | | | | | |Create a new | | | | | | |rule 1.3 under | | | | | | |the heading | | | | | | |FIRST SACRED | | | | | | |LAW with the | | | | | | |text: | | | | | | |Whenever a | | | | | | |player | | | | | | |Registers and | | | | | | |the number of | | | | | | |Therms exceeds | | | | | | |the number of | | | | | | |players by at | | | | | | |least five, all| | | | | | |players recieve| | | | | | |a Coin and the | | | | | | |number of | | | | | | |Therms is set | | | | | | |to zero. | | | | | | | | | | | | | |Destroy rule | | | | | | |2.1 | | | | | | |Create a new | | | | | | |rule 2.1 under | | | | | | |the heading | | | | | | |SECOND SACRED | | | | | | |LAW with the | | | | | | |text: | | | | | | |Any player who | | | | | | |submits a | | | | | | |proposal that | | | | | | |would destroy | | | | | | |at least three | | | | | | |Things recieves| | | | | | |a Coin if that | | | | | | |proposal | | | | | | |passes. | | | | | | | | | | | | | |Players are | | | | | | |hereby reminded| | | | | | |that the above | | | | | | |two changes | | | | | | |alter the Three| | | | | | |Sacred Laws. | | | | | | |Thus, NO votes | | | | | | |are vetoes and | | | | | | |ABSTAIN votes | | | | | | |are like normal| | | | | | |NO votes. It is| | | | | | |therefore | | | | | | |important to | | | | | | |vote, and since| | | | | | |these are minor| | | | | | |changes players| | | | | | |are asked to | | | | | | |ABSTAIN rather | | | | | | |than vetoing | | | | | | |the proposal | | | | | | |unless they see| | | | | | |some gaping | | | | | | |flaw that was | | | | | | |missed in | | | | | | |earlier | | | | | | |discussion. Of | | | | | | |course, this | | | | | | |paragraph has | | | | | | |no force, but | | | | | | |it is here as a| | | | | | |reminder. | | | | |--+-------------+---------------+--------------+--------+---------------| |17|"minor ensp |If the proposal|Submitted on |FOR: |-1R | | |fix" |'Eco Nomic |Tue Apr 22, |bd |+1R | | | |Stimulus |2003 at |Craig |________ | | | |Package' has |12:23pm by |unlin_e |+0 things | | | |passed, destroy|Craig. |AGAINST:|+1 Therm | | | |rule 9.1 and | |ABSTAIN:| | | | |create a new |Pending |Dr | | | | |rule 9.1 with | |Ducker | | | | |the text: |Will expire on|NO VOTE | | | | |Rules, players,|Tue Apr 29, |YET: | | | | |proposals, |2003 at |Josh | | | | |offices, coins,|12:23pm. |UNABLE | | | | |and The Bank | |TO VOTE:| | | | |are things. | |(Cassie)| | | | | | |(Ian) | | |--+-------------+---------------+--------------+--------+---------------| |18|"free trade" |A rule 0.5 will|Submitted on |FOR: | | | | |be created, |Thu Apr 24, |Craig | | | | |reading "There |2003 at |AGAINST:| | | | |are no |10:36pm by |ABSTAIN:| | | | |restrictions on|Craig. |NO VOTE | | | | |players | |YET: | | | | |entering the |Pending |bd | | | | |Nomic Market." | |Dr | | | | | | |Ducker | | | | |ThermodyNomic | |Josh | | | | |will officially| |unlin_e | | | | |ask to be | |UNABLE | | | | |recognized as a| |TO VOTE:| | | | |participant by | |(Cassie)| | | | |the Nomic | |(Ian) | | | | |Market. | | | | | | | | | | | | | |This proposal | | | | | | |shall be | | | | | | |destroyed. | | | | |--+-------------+---------------+--------------+--------+---------------| |19|"hot |The text "hot |Submitted on |FOR: |Can't Fail. | | |potatoes" |potatoes, " |Sun Apr 27, |bd | | | | |will be |2003 at 6:26pm|Craig | | | | |inserted before|by Craig. |Dr | | | | |the word "and" | |Ducker | | | | |in rule 9.1 and|Pending |Josh | | | | |the resulting | |AGAINST:| | | | |string will be | |ABSTAIN:| | | | |known as | |NO VOTE | | | | |NEWTEXT for the| |YET: | | | | |purposes of | |unlin_e | | | | |this proposal, | |UNABLE | | | | |so that we | |TO VOTE:| | | | |don't have to | |(Cassie)| | | | |worry about | |(Ian) | | | | |other | | | | | | |additions. | | | | | | |Rule 9.1 will | | | | | | |be repealed, | | | | | | |and a new rule | | | | | | |9.1 whose text | | | | | | |is NEWTEXT will| | | | | | |be created. | | | | | | | | | | | | | |A group will be| | | | | | |created with | | | | | | |the heading | | | | | | |POTATOES. | | | | | | |A rule 15.0 | | | | | | |will be created| | | | | | |in that group | | | | | | |with the text | | | | | | |"Each Hot | | | | | | |Potato must | | | | | | |have its own | | | | | | |unique name, | | | | | | |and it must | | | | | | |also have a | | | | | | |description of | | | | | | |when its effect| | | | | | |occurs and what| | | | | | |that effect | | | | | | |is." | | | | | | |The comment for| | | | | | |POTATOES will | | | | | | |be as follows: | | | | | | |"The intent of | | | | | | |these rules is | | | | | | |that hot | | | | | | |potatoes will | | | | | | |be created | | | | | | |which in some | | | | | | |way harm their | | | | | | |posessors, so | | | | | | |that players | | | | | | |will | | | | | | |frantically | | | | | | |give them to | | | | | | |one another as | | | | | | |the appointed | | | | | | |time draws | | | | | | |near." | | | | | | | | | | | | | |This proposal | | | | | | |is destroyed. | | | | |--+-------------+---------------+--------------+--------+---------------| |20|"cash flow" |A hot potato |Submitted on |FOR: | | | | |shall be |Sun Apr 27, |Craig | | | | |created, called|2003 at 7:03 |AGAINST:| | | | |the Potato of |pm by Craig. |bd | | | | |Cash Flow. Its | |ABSTAIN:| | | | |description |Not Pending |NO VOTE | | | | |shall be "Every|due to TSL |YET: | | | | |time Yahoo |violations |Dr | | | | |automatically | |Ducker | | | | |posts the | |Josh | | | | |ruleset, each | |unlin_e | | | | |Coin belonging | |UNABLE | | | | |to the posessor| |TO VOTE:| | | | |of this hot | |(Cassie)| | | | |potato will be | |(Ian) | | | | |given to a | | | | | | |random player."| | | | | | |The group | | | | | | |owner, who is | | | | | | |also the | | | | | | |submitter of | | | | | | |the proposal, | | | | | | |promises not to| | | | | | |change the | | | | | | |frequency of | | | | | | |such | | | | | | |occurrences. | | | | | | |The Potato of | | | | | | |Cash Flow shall| | | | | | |begin in the | | | | | | |posession of a | | | | | | |random player. | | | | |--+-------------+---------------+--------------+--------+---------------| |21|"cash flow |A hot potato |Submitted on |FOR: |Can't Fail. | | |take 2" |shall be |Sun Apr 27, |bd | | | | |created, called|2003 at 7:38pm|Craig | | | | |the Potato of |by Craig. |Josh | | | | |Cash Flow. Its | |AGAINST:| | | | |description |Pending |ABSTAIN:| | | | |shall be | |NO VOTE | | | | |"Whenever the | |YET: | | | | |Potato of Cash | |Dr | | | | |Flow has gone | |Ducker | | | | |two full weeks | |unlin_e | | | | |without causing| |UNABLE | | | | |any Things to | |TO VOTE:| | | | |be | |(Cassie)| | | | |redistributed, | |(Ian) | | | | |the Potato of | | | | | | |Cash Flow and | | | | | | |each Coin | | | | | | |belonging to | | | | | | |its posessor | | | | | | |will be given | | | | | | |to a random | | | | | | |player." The | | | | | | |Potato of Cash | | | | | | |Flow shall | | | | | | |begin in the | | | | | | |posession of a | | | | | | |random player. | | | | | | |This proposal | | | | | | |shall be | | | | | | |destroyed. | | | | |--+-------------+---------------+--------------+--------+---------------| |22| | | |FOR: | | | | | | |AGAINST:| | | | | | |ABSTAIN:| | | | | | |NO VOTE | | | | | | |YET: | | | | | | |bd | | | | | | |Craig | | | | | | |Dr | | | | | | |Ducker | | | | | | |Josh | | | | | | |unlin_e | | | | | | |UNABLE | | | | | | |TO VOTE:| | | | | | |(Cassie)| | | | | | |(Ian) | | +------------------------------------------------------------------------+ Calls For Judgement: +------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | |CFJ Body |CFJ Status |Judgement |Appellate |Notes | | | | | |Judgement | | |--+----------------+-----------+--------------+----------------+--------| |1 |14.1 This thing |Submitted |FALSE | | | | |is a rule. |on Thu 10 | | | | | | |Apr 2003 at| | | | | | |11:42pm by | | | | | | |bd. | | | | | | | | | | | | | |Assigned to| | | | | | |Cassie for | | | | | | |Judgement. | | | | |--+----------------+-----------+--------------+----------------+--------| |2 |14.2 This thing |Submitted |TRUE | |Written | | |is a rule. |on Thu 10 | | |into the| | | |Apr 2003 at| | |rules on| | | |11:42pm by | | |Fri Apr | | | |bd. | | |25, 2003| | | | | | |at | | | |Assigned to| | |2:57pm | | | |unlin_e for| | | | | | |Judgement. | | | | |--+----------------+-----------+--------------+----------------+--------| |3 |14.3 This thing |Submitted |FALSE | | | | |is a rule. |on Thu 10 |I do so due to| | | | | |Apr 2003 at|the fact that | | | | | |11:42pm by |this CFJ | | | | | |bd. |contains a | | | | | | |number which | | | | | |Assigned to|is not | | | | | |Dr Ducker |necessarily | | | | | |for |the rule | | | | | |Judgement. |number under | | | | | | |which it would| | | | | | |be added | | | | | | |according to | | | | | | |rules 13.0 and| | | | | | |13.1 . | | | |--+----------------+-----------+--------------+----------------+--------| |4 |14.4 This thing |Submitted |FALSE | | | | |is a rule. |on Thu 10 | | | | | | |Apr 2003 at| | | | | | |11:42pm by | | | | | | |bd. | | | | | | | | | | | | | |Assigned to| | | | | | |Cassie for | | | | | | |Judgement. | | | | |--+----------------+-----------+--------------+----------------+--------| |5 |14.5 This thing |Submitted |FALSE | | | | |is a rule. |on Thu 10 | | | | | | |Apr 2003 at| | | | | | |11:42pm by | | | | | | |bd. | | | | | | | | | | | | | |Assigned to| | | | | | |Craig for | | | | | | |Judgement. | | | | |--+----------------+-----------+--------------+----------------+--------| |6 |The title of |Submitted |FALSE | | | | |section 14 is |on Thu 10 |There is no | | | | |'Extra rules'. |Apr 2003 at|"section 14" | | | | | |11:42pm by |at the time | | | | |The comment of |bd. |that this Call| | | | |section 14 is | |for Judgement | | | | |'These are used |Assigned to|was made, | | | | |in the early |Dr Ducker |therefore | | | | |game to allow |for |neither | | | | |the ruleset to |Judgement. |sentence can | | | | |grow.' | |be considered | | | | | | |to be true. | | | | | | |Had the CFJ | | | | | | |referred | | | | | | |simply to "a | | | | | | |new section", | | | | | | |or even better| | | | | | |had it | | | | | | |conditionally | | | | | | |specified the | | | | | | |creation of a | | | | | | |section, then | | | | | | |it is possible| | | | | | |I could have | | | | | | |judged this | | | | | | |true. | | | | | | |For instance | | | | | | |if the Call | | | | | | |had read: | | | | | | |"If this | | | | | | |sentence is | | | | | | |added to the | | | | | | |ruleset, then,| | | | | | |at that time, | | | | | | |a new group of| | | | | | |rules is | | | | | | |created, which| | | | | | |is entitled | | | | | | |'Extra Rules',| | | | | | |which contains| | | | | | |the comment | | | | | | |'These are | | | | | | |used in the | | | | | | |early game to | | | | | | |allow the | | | | | | |ruleset to | | | | | | |grow.', and | | | | | | |which contains| | | | | | |any rules | | | | | | |whose number | | | | | | |is greater | | | | | | |than or equal | | | | | | |to 14.0 and | | | | | | |less than 15.0| | | | | | |." | | | |--+----------------+-----------+--------------+----------------+--------| |7 |The proposal, |Submitted |FALSE |Cassie: | | | |known as |on Thu Apr | | | | | |"Proposal 1", |10, 2003 at| |Craig: TRUE | | | |Submitted on |11:08pm by | | | | | |Thursday, the |Dr Ducker. | |unlin_e: | | | |10th of April | | | | | | |2003 at 10:44am |Assigned to| | | | | |by Cassie |bd for | | | | | |Harley, was |Judgement. | | | | | |submitted | | | | | | |illegally under |Apealled on| | | | | |Rule 1.1 . |Sun Apr 13,| | | | | | |2003 at | | | | | | |9:05am by | | | | | | |Dr Ducker. | | | | | | | | | | | | | |Assigned to| | | | | | |Cassie, | | | | | | |Craig and | | | | | | |unlin_e for| | | | | | |Appellate | | | | | | |Judgement. | | | | |--+----------------+-----------+--------------+----------------+--------| |8 |The proposal, |Submitted | | | | | |known as |on Thu Apr | | | | | |"Proposal 3", |10, 2003 at| | | | | |Submitted on |11:08pm by | | | | | |Thursday, the |Dr Ducker. | | | | | |10th of April | | | | | | |2003 at 10:16pm |Assigned to| | | | | |by unlin_e, was |Cassie for | | | | | |submitted |Judgement. | | | | | |illegally under | | | | | | |Rule 1.1 . | | | | | |--+----------------+-----------+--------------+----------------+--------| |9 |Rule 7.3 did not|i Submitted| | | | | |destroy any |on Fri Apr | | | | | |points upon |11, 2003 at| | | | | |Josh's |3:39am by | | | | | |deregistration |Craig. | | | | | |of April 10, | | | | | | |2003, as there |Assigned to| | | | | |was nothing to |unlin_e for| | | | | |destroy. |Judgement. | | | | |--+----------------+-----------+--------------+----------------+--------| |10|Rule 7.3 |Submitted |TRUE |Cassie: |Would | | |decreased the |on Fri Apr |It decreased | |have | | |number of points|11, 2003 at|his points by |Dr Ducker: |been | | |in the game by 1|3:39am by |one, making |FALSE |written | | |upon Josh's |Craig. |his points |In examining |into the| | |deregistration. | |negative. This|this CFJ, the |rules on| | | |Assigned to|was then |question seems |Fri Apr | | |A random player |bd for |distributed |to be are the |25, 2003| | |must therefore |Judgement. |randomly. |phrases, "one of|at | | |receive a | | |eir points is |8:25pm | | |negative number |Appealled | |destroyed" and | | | |of points. |on Fri Apr | |"decreased the | | | | |18, 2003 at| |number of points| | | | |4:57pm by | |in the game", | | | | |Craig. | |equivalent. | | | | | | |First, it seems | | | | |Assigned to| |to me that the | | | | |Cassie, Dr | |text of rule 7.3| | | | |Ducker, and| |is specific to a| | | | |Josh for | |point in the | | | | |Appellate | |possession of | | | | |Judgement. | |the player in | | | | | | |question, and | | | | | | |not simply more | | | | | | |generally within| | | | | | |the game. If | | | | | | |Josh had had a | | | | | | |point when he | | | | | | |deregistered | | | | | | |then the effect | | | | | | |of | | | | | | |deregistration | | | | | | |would trivially | | | | | | |prove this CFJ | | | | | | |true, however, | | | | | | |since Josh did | | | | | | |not have a point| | | | | | |when he | | | | | | |deregistered the| | | | | | |question then | | | | | | |appears to shift| | | | | | |to whether a | | | | | | |non-existant | | | | | | |Thing can be | | | | | | |destroyed. | | | | | | |This issue seems| | | | | | |to go to the | | | | | | |spirit of the | | | | | | |game as a whole,| | | | | | |and it seems to | | | | | | |me to be against| | | | | | |that spirit to | | | | | | |have "negative" | | | | | | |Things. | | | | | | | | | | | | | |Additionally, I | | | | | | |find the second | | | | | | |sentence to be | | | | | | |dangerously | | | | | | |ambiguous as a | | | | | | |stand-alone | | | | | | |rule, which it | | | | | | |would become if | | | | | | |this CFJ is | | | | | | |found true. | | | | | | | | | | | | | |Josh: FALSE | | |--+----------------+-----------+--------------+----------------+--------| |11|When a proposal |Submitted |FALSE |bd:FALSE | | | |creates a rule |on Sat Apr |The sole | | | | |which declares a|12, 2003 at|purpose of the|Cassie: | | | |Thing to exist, |2:00pm by |action which | | | | |the proposal is |Craig. |has instigated|unlin_e:FALSE | | | |not seen as | |this Call for | | | | |directly |Assigned to|Judgement is | | | | |creating that |Dr Ducker |to create a | | | | |Thing for the |for |singular new | | | | |purposes of the |Judgement. |Thing (The | | | | |First Sacred | |office of the | | | | |Law. |Apealled on|Stenotype), | | | | | |Sun Apr 13,|therefore its | | | | | |2003 at |creation would| | | | | |2:45pm by |be a direct | | | | | |Craig. |result of the | | | | | | |passing of the| | | | | |Assigned to|proposal | | | | | |bd, Cassie,|containing | | | | | |and unlin_e|said action. | | | | | |for |If the action | | | | | |Appellate |in question | | | | | |Judgement. |had specified | | | | | | |a conditional,| | | | | | |even one that | | | | | | |was satisfied | | | | | | |at the time of| | | | | | |the containing| | | | | | |proposals | | | | | | |passage, then | | | | | | |the creation | | | | | | |of the office | | | | | | |would not have| | | | | | |been a direct | | | | | | |result of the | | | | | | |proposals | | | | | | |passage. Even | | | | | | |something as | | | | | | |simple as: | | | | | | |" | | | | | | |Rule 10.5 is | | | | | | |created in the| | | | | | |group OFFICES,| | | | | | |reading: | | | | | | |At the time of| | | | | | |this rules | | | | | | |creation, a | | | | | | |new office | | | | | | |known as the | | | | | | |Stenotype is | | | | | | |created, whose| | | | | | |possessor, the| | | | | | |Stenographer, | | | | | | |is responsible| | | | | | |for tracking | | | | | | |all past | | | | | | |judgements and| | | | | | |for assigning | | | | | | |Judges and | | | | | | |Appelate | | | | | | |Justices. | | | | | | |" | | | | | | | | | | | | | |This would | | | | | | |also separate | | | | | | |the office | | | | | | |from its | | | | | | |creating rule | | | | | | |for SSL | | | | | | |purposes. But,| | | | | | |be careful | | | | | | |with needing | | | | | | |to modify the | | | | | | |office later, | | | | | | |10.5 should | | | | | | |not be | | | | | | |destroyed and | | | | | | |re-created | | | | | | |with the same | | | | | | |initial | | | | | | |phrase, as | | | | | | |that would | | | | | | |create a | | | | | | |second | | | | | | |Stenotype, | | | | | | |rather, a new | | | | | | |rule would | | | | | | |need to be | | | | | | |added with the| | | | | | |appropriate | | | | | | |modifications | | | | | | |contained | | | | | | |within it. | | | |--+----------------+-----------+--------------+----------------+--------| |12|The statement of|Submitted |FALSE | | | | |the judge in |on Thu Apr | | | | | |rule 11.5 refers|17, 2003 at| | | | | |only to the one |1:38am by | | | | | |which delivers |Craig. | | | | | |judgement. | | | | | | | |Assigned to| | | | | | |Dr Ducker | | | | | | |for | | | | | | |Judgement. | | | | |--+----------------+-----------+--------------+----------------+--------| |13|A judge whose |Submitted |FALSE | | | | |judgement has |on Thu Apr | | | | | |not been |17, 2003 at| | | | | |appealed may |1:38am by | | | | | |reverse eir |Craig. | | | | | |judgement. | | | | | | | |Assigned to| | | | | | |bd for | | | | | | |Judgement. | | | | |--+----------------+-----------+--------------+----------------+--------| |14|A judge whose |Submitted |FALSE | | | | |judgement has |on Thu Apr | | | | | |been appealed |17, 2003 at| | | | | |may reverse eir |1:38am by | | | | | |judgement until |Craig. | | | | | |all three | | | | | | |appelate |Assigned to| | | | | |justices have |bd for | | | | | |returned a |Judgement. | | | | | |verdict. | | | | | |--+----------------+-----------+--------------+----------------+--------| |15|An appelate |Submitted |FALSE | | | | |justice may |on Thu Apr | | | | | |reverse eir |17, 2003 at| | | | | |judgement until |1:38am by | | | | | |all three |Craig. | | | | | |appelate | | | | | | |justices have |Assigned to| | | | | |returned a |unlin_e for| | | | | |verdict. |Judgement. | | | | |--+----------------+-----------+--------------+----------------+--------| |16|A registration |Submitted |FALSE | | | | |proposal is |on Fri Apr | | | | | |identical to a |25, 2003 at| | | | | |proposal in all |8:11am by | | | | | |respects, |Dr Ducker | | | | | |except, that | | | | | | |until such time |Assigned to| | | | | |as it passes, it|bd for | | | | | |is not a Thing, |Judgement. | | | | | |and therefore | | | | | | |need not be | | | | | | |possessed by | | | | | | |anyone or | | | | | | |anything. | | | | | | | | | | | | | |A registration | | | | | | |proposal which | | | | | | |passes becomes a| | | | | | |normal proposal,| | | | | | |and thus a | | | | | | |Thing, in the | | | | | | |possession of | | | | | | |the submitter of| | | | | | |the proposal. | | | | | | | | | | | | | |A registration | | | | | | |proposal which | | | | | | |fails to pass | | | | | | |also fails to | | | | | | |become a Thing. | | | | | |--+----------------+-----------+--------------+----------------+--------| |17|It is not |Submitted |TRUE | |Will be | | |necessary for a |on Sat Apr |8.x specifies | |written | | |registration |26, 2003 at|that | |into the| | |proposal to have|1:52am by |non-players | |ruleset | | |a posessor. |Craig |can submit | |on Sat | | | | |registration | |May 3, | | | |Assigned to|proposals. | |2003 at | | | |bd for |This takes | |1:57 am | | | |Judgement |precedence | | | | | | |over 9.7 . | | | |--+----------------+-----------+--------------+----------------+--------| |18| | | | | | +------------------------------------------------------------------------+