Cycle 0 Votes:Cycle 1 Title Proposer Mac Puzz Sed Kevan VickiLyn Façade Id Malaprop Result Karma 1.1 U.N. McNomic Kevan FOR FOR FOR FOR FOR AGAINST AGAINST AGAINST PASSES 5 1.2 Ballad of McNomic Kevan FOR FOR FOR FOR FOR AGAINST AGAINST FOR PASSES 6 1.3 Powerful Chiselling Kevan FOR FOR FOR FOR FOR FOR AGAINST FOR PASSES 7 1.4 Nit-Picking Kevan AGAINST AGAINST FOR FOR AGAINST FOR AGAINST AGAINST FAILS -5 1.5 The Voting Golem Kevan AGAINST FOR FOR FOR AGAINST FOR AGAINST AGAINST FAILS (tie) -4 1.6 Calvinball Kevan FOR FOR FOR FOR AGAINST AGAINST FOR FOR PASSES 6 1.7 The Better Mousetrap Kevan AGAINST AGAINST FOR FOR AGAINST FOR AGAINST AGAINST FAILS -5 (10 to Kevan) 1.8 How's my Karma? Id FOR FOR FOR FOR UNDECIDED FOR FOR FOR PASSES 7 1.9 Titular Locomotion Id FOR FOR FOR FOR FOR AGAINST FOR FOR PASSES 7 (14 to Id) 1.10 EAPTRMFD Malaprop FOR FOR FOR AGAINST AGAINST FOR FOR FOR PASSES 6 1.11 Enquiring minds ... (revised) Malaprop AGAINST AGAINST FOR FOR AGAINST FOR AGAINST FOR FAILS (tie) -4 1.12 Evo-Nomic Malaprop FOR FOR AGAINST FOR FOR FOR FOR FOR PASSES 7 ( 9 to Malaprop) 1.13 Delegation's The Plan Puzz FOR FOR FOR FOR FOR AGAINST AGAINST UNDECIDED PASSES 5 1.14 Back Up Moderator Puzz FOR FOR FOR AGAINST FOR UNDECIDED AGAINST AGAINST PASSES 4 ( 9 to Puzz) 1.15 The Big Brother Chase Mac FOR FOR FOR FOR FOR FOR AGAINST FOR PASSES 7 1.16 Custodianship of Ruleset Rv. Mac FOR FOR FOR FOR FOR UNDECIDED FOR FOR PASSES 7 1.17 The Interlude Chase Mac FOR FOR FOR FOR FOR AGAINST FOR UNDECIDED PASSES 6 (20 to Mac) Karma: For Pass 13 13 12 11 10 5 7 9 For Fail 0 -1 -4 -4 0 -4 0 -1 Against Fail 4 3 0 0 4 0 4 3 Against Pass 0 0 -1 -2 -2 -6 -6 -2 Proposal success 20 9 10 14 9 Karmic Change: 37 26 7 15 12 -5 19 18